Parliament disruption hurts opposition too – Pranab Mukherjee’s farewell speech

Parliament disruption hurts opposition too – Pranab Mukherjee’s farewell speech
Written by Karu Cheema

Outgoing President Pranab Mukherjee gave a word of advise to both government and opposition, telling them ordinance route should be used only in compelling circumstances and disruption of parliament harms the opposition too. He also said passing bills without sound discussion is a breach of trust. Addressing a farewell function held in the Central Hall of parliament by the members of both houses, Mukherjee described himself as “humble servant” of people who had sought to preserve, protect and defend the Constitution in both word and spirit.

A nostalgic Mukherjee, who will demit office on Tuesday, recalled that he was only 34 years old when he first entered parliament in 1969 as a Rajya Sabha MP and went on to complete 37 years as a parliamentarian – where he “understood the real value of debate, discussion and dissent” – before being elected to the highest constitutional post. Lok Sabha Speaker Sumitra Mahajan read out the farewell address by the lower house’s members, describing him a “guru” from whom generations of parliamentarians have received lessons on operational dynamics of parliamentary practice.

Vice President Hamid Ansari, who is also Chairman of Rajya Sabha, cited Mukherjee’s remarks at a farewell dinner for Governors and Lt Governors last week in which he had said that their role is “mainly confined to giving advice to Chief Minister” as “there cannot be two functional executive authorities in a state”.

The function was attended by Prime Minister Narendra Modi, Congress president Sonia Gandhi, union ministers, senior leaders from the opposition besides present and former MPs. Former Prime Ministers H. D. Deve Gowda and Manmohan Singh were among those present.

Mukherjee was presented a scroll, a memento and a book containing signatures of the parliamentarians. In his speech, which received repeated applause, the president addressed both the government and the opposition.

“I am firm in my opinion that the ordinance route should be used only in compelling circumstances and there should be no recourse to ordinances on monetary matters,” he said, adding it should not be brought on matters pending in the house or before a committee and if a matter is deemed urgent, the committee should be asked to present its report in a stipulated time.

He said it is “unfortunate” that parliament’s time devoted to legislation has been declining. “With heightened complexity of administration, legislation must be preceded by scrutiny and adequate discussion. Scrutiny in committees is no substitute to open discussion on the floor of the House.

“When Parliament fails to discharge its law making role, or enacts laws without discussion, it breaches the trust reposed in it by the people,” he added. Mukherjee said he realised as a parliamentarian that disruptions of proceedings “hurts the opposition more than the government as it denies them the opportunity to raise the concerns of the people”.

Mukherjee remembered his “mentor”, former Prime Minister Indira Gandhi, terming her a “towering personality” who had the courage to call a spade a spade. Praised Prime Minister Narendra Modi, he said he had greatly benefited in his task of protecting and preserving constitution by advice and cooperation given by Modi at every step.

“With passion and energy, he is driving transformation changes in the country. I will carry with me fond memories of our association and his warm and courteous behavior,” he said.

Mukherjee rued that as he retires, his association with Parliament will also end. “It will be with a tinge of sadness and a rainbow of memories that I will be leaving this magnificent building today,” he added.

“With a sense of gratitude and a prayer in my heart, I take leave of you. I leave with a sense of fulfillment and happiness of having served the people of this great country through this institution — as their humble servant.”

Mukherjee said his long innings in Parliament was both instructive and educative and recalled contributions of several leaders including former Prime Ministers P.V. Narasimha Rao, Atal Bihari Vajpayee and Manmohan Singh, BJP leader L.K. Advani and Congress president Sonia Gandhi.

About the author

Karu Cheema

In the depth of the world seeking opinions and lot more, I found my passion in these thoughts, The world is simple word bringing us profound touch locked in the world of words. Was born with soulful passion of becoming a writer, having seek this career is best side of me. I am looking forward to light up this world through the words that can touch everyone's mindfulness.